2004 - ReNae (Patterson) Smith

2005 - Staci Sivinski

2006 - Amelia Elliott

2007 - Dani Jo (Lange) Rueter

2008 - Jessica (Rausch) Wimmer

2009 - Melissa Take

2010 - Tally (Roepke) Goosen

2011 - Kearsten Brown

2012 - Jaci Hermstead

2023 - Paige Stewert